Self-Tanning Mistakes You’re Probably Making—and How to Fix Them

A good self-tan can make you look well-rested, glowing, and like you just came back from a long weekend somewhere warm. A bad one… well, that’s a different story. The good news? Most self-tanning mishaps come down to a few very common mistakes - and they’re all easy to fix.

Let’s break down what might be going wrong and how to get that smooth, natural-looking glow every time.

Mistake #1: Skipping Proper Prep

Self-tanner loves a smooth canvas. Dry patches, leftover lotion, or flaky skin can cause color to cling in all the wrong places - hello, knees, elbows, and ankles.

The fix: Exfoliate 24 hours before tanning, focusing on areas where skin is thicker or drier. Use a gentle scrub or exfoliating mitt, then moisturize well. On tanning day, apply a light layer of lotion to elbows, knees, hands, and feet so the color blends more seamlessly. Grab my favorite exfoliating glove here.

Mistake #2: Applying on Damp or Oily Skin

Applying self-tanner right after a shower - or over heavy body oils - can dilute the formula and lead to streaking or uneven development.

The fix: Make sure your skin is completely dry and free of oils before application. If you’ve just showered, give your skin a few minutes to cool and dry fully. Clean, dry skin helps the color develop evenly and last longer.

Mistake #3: Using Too Much Product

I've never been accused of being a Less is More kind of girl... but more product doesn’t mean deeper glow - it usually means darker patches and longer blend time (and sometimes regret).

The fix: Start with less than you think you need. Build the color gradually and use a tanning mitt to blend evenly. You can always add another layer the next day, but fixing an over-applied tan takes a lot more effort.

Mistake #4: Forgetting About Hands, Feet, and Face

These areas tend to absorb color faster and show mistakes more easily, which is why they’re often the giveaway of a self-tan.

The fix: Use what’s left on your mitt - don’t apply fresh product. Blend lightly and buff thoroughly. For the face, opt for a tanning mist or drops designed specifically for facial skin and apply sparingly. Want to try my go-to face tanning mist? Grab it HERE.

Mistake #5: Getting Dressed Too Soon

We’ve all been there - throwing on clothes too quickly and hoping for the best. Unfortunately, that’s a fast track to streaks and uneven color transfer.

The fix: Give your self-tan enough time to dry before dressing. Wear loose, dark clothing for the first few hours and avoid tight straps, denim, or anything that rubs while the tan develops.

Mistake #6: Expecting It to Last Forever

A self-tan fades naturally as your skin renews itself, and without maintenance, it can disappear faster than you’d like.

The fix: Hydrate daily with a lightweight moisturizer to extend the life of your tan. Gentle exfoliation and a light touch-up mid-week can keep your glow looking fresh and even.

Final Glow Tip

Self-tanning shouldn’t feel stressful or intimidating. With the right prep, a little patience, and a lighter hand, you can achieve a natural, sun-kissed glow that looks effortless—because it should be.

When in doubt, keep it simple, blend well, and remember: a good self-tan enhances your skin, it doesn’t announce itself.

Glow on, Babes. ✨

XOXO, CAP